To me, one of many things that separates the pros from the joes is if they can distinguish authentic children’s work. Can you? 🙂
Contrast these images with an image search of “authentic children’s bulletin boards” Indeed, the bulletin board is the worst offender. Usually completely designed and conceptualized by the teacher, the child simply paints his or her circle green and the teacher assembles it into a caterpillar, plant or leprechaun. The child has absolutely no idea why he is glueing cotton balls onto lambs or cutting strips of paper for a lions whiskers….
So let’s take a look at some ACTUAL work of children….
At first glance, the taping of the doors makes you mad. “Who taped the doors?” you want to say. But wait a minute and look at the larger picture. This is a fully purposeful taping. They are taped to prevent them from opening and so to keep the tension on the rope tight.
— Heidi Echternacht (@hechternacht) December 11, 2014
I think they were measuring the length of the cabinet and realized they couldn’t hold two rulers there so they taped it. Totally logical.
Contrast this completely student created center on “Horses” with the former science curriculum consisting of guessing how many seeds were inside the pumpkin and then counting them. Do we care?
This student included skeletal models of horses, research books and a book she wrote with a partner. A teacher never would have thought to include horse jumps in a science center on horses….
Making a “soup”. We later noted that the beans puffed up when they were in the water, but the popcorn did not.
When you lose it behind the bookcase, it’s lost. Unless you can devise a system for retrieving it… 🙂
What does this say about this student in math?
This child’s self-designed project simply involved folding paper and counting the squares. Wallah, multiplication.
So this child made the flag, now how to get it to stand up? Well tuck it into the tape dispenser, obviously….
When teachers say they “have the students come up with the class rules” at the beginning of the year, do they look like this?
Art The scrap box is a fantastic source of art.
I just have to include this because I think its absolutely incredible
This is a whole ‘nother topic I’ll leave for a next post, but here’s a related project
Well taped to the wall, this authentic student work lays out the plan for how to get a turn (you only get one) and write your name on the piece of paper. The student also has started to list the individual classrooms by grade (1C, etc)
This student driven project blurs into STEM as we work to design “non-fiction” centers. The ballet studio was a busy hub for weeks.
Authentic student work is completely driven by the student. The teacher is there to guide, question and help form the habits of mind and culture that takes the child to the next level of wherever it is that they are.
Can YOU recognize where students are? Can YOU discern REAL authentic children’s work?